The LLoyd blog: hidden talent.

The Pros and Cons of Temporary vs. Permanent Jobs

temporary vs permanent
temporary vs. permanent


Temporary work – a category of employment once seen merely as a stopgap measure for job seekers between jobs or for actresses and artists waiting for their big break, has transformed into a respected and strategic option for many workers. Employers use temporary workers for flexible staffing needs and as a smart strategy for managing seasonal workloads or peak projects. Understanding the pros and cons of temporary work compared to permanent jobs is crucial for anyone navigating their career path and deciding which might be the right option for them.

The Evolution of Temporary Work

In the 1970s, temp jobs were often viewed as low-skilled, short-term positions primarily filled by people looking for extra income. These roles were typically administrative or clerical and lacked the respect or benefits associated with permanent jobs. Temp workers were often seen as second-tier employees, only brought in to cover for permanent staff during absences or busy periods.

Fast forward to today, and the landscape of temporary work has changed dramatically. Modern temping spans a wide range of industries and skill levels, from entry-level administrative roles to high-level project management and specialized technical positions, as well as executive and interim leadership. The rise of the gig economy and advancements in technology have further propelled this shift, making temporary work a viable and attractive option for many professionals who value a sense of freedom and control over their career options.

temporary vs permanent
temporary work

According to the American Staffing Association (ASA), more than 3 million temporary and/or contract employees work for America’s staffing companies during an average week, highlighting the growing acceptance and importance of temporary work in the current workforce.  Most temporary associates are affiliated with one core or a few key staffing firms who keep them working as steadily as they want to be.  As the firm’s associate, they are the staffing firm’s employee and are paid by the staffing firm, not the company where they are assigned.  The American Staffing Association offers a good basic overview of why to work for a staffing agency.

Temporary jobs, often facilitated through staffing agencies like Lloyd Staffing, are typically for a set period. These positions can come with similar benefits to permanent roles, but are limited in duration. Temp jobs can range from administrative support to very specialized project-based or technical roles. They can be for a day, a week, a year or longer – and any time in between.

The Advantages of Temporary Work

Temporary jobs can serve as an invaluable bridge to permanent employment. Many employers use temp roles to evaluate potential long-term hires, making it a strategic entry point for job seekers. Additionally, temping allows individuals to gain diverse and extensive experience across different industries and roles, building a robust and versatile skill set. It also offers a chance to expand one’s professional network, exposing temp workers to a wide range of contacts and increasing future job opportunities.

Flexibility is another significant aspect of temporary work. It allows for varied work hours and job locations, accommodating personal schedules and lifestyle preferences. This can be particularly beneficial for those balancing multiple commitments or seeking to explore different career paths without long-term commitment. Moreover, the variety inherent in temporary work keeps things interesting, preventing the monotony that can accompany long-term roles.

Temporary positions often offer a quicker route to employment compared to permanent roles, providing immediate income and work experience. This can be a crucial lifeline for those in between jobs, reducing financial stress and keeping resumes active. The adaptability developed through regularly changing jobs is a highly valued skill a world that values agility and resilience. Temping fosters this adaptability by exposing workers to new environments, new people and state of the trends and practices.


The Challenges of Temporary Work 

temporary vs permanent
temporary vs. permanent

However, temporary work does come with its challenges. One of the most significant drawbacks is the lack of benefits. Many temporary positions do not offer health insurance, retirement plans, or paid time off, which can be a considerable downside for many; however, staffing firms intent on attracting top caliber talent have made significant inroads to provide the temporary associates with things like healthcare coverage, paid time off and 401K options. Job security is another concern; the inherent short-term nature of temp work means there is less stability compared to permanent roles.

Social isolation can be a real issue for some temporary employees, who may feel excluded from the permanent team and miss out on the camaraderie and support that comes with long-term employment. This sense of being an outsider can be exacerbated by the perception and treatment of temps, who may face the “just a temp” attitude from permanent staff and be assigned less desirable and often monotonous responsibilities.

The limited power and influence of temporary workers can also be frustrating. With less say in workplace decisions and policies, temps may feel like they have little control over their work environment. Additionally, the inconsistent nature of temp work can lead to periods of unemployment, making financial planning difficult.

Temporary roles might offer fewer opportunities for advancement within a company, and the dependency on staffing agencies for placements can sometimes lead to uncertainty and lack of control over job assignments. Furthermore, employers may invest less in the training and development of temporary workers, affecting their professional growth. The constant transition between jobs can take an emotional toll, causing uncertainty about the future.
Bottomline – some individuals thrive on the temporary work lifestyle, others find it stressful.

temporary vs permanent
temporary vs. permanent
temporary vs permanent
temporary vs. permanent


The Benefits of Permanent Jobs

On the other hand, permanent jobs provide long-term security and a consistent income, which is reassuring for many workers. Permanent positions usually come with a full suite of employee benefits, including health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave, providing a safety net that temp jobs often lack.

Long-term roles offer clear opportunities for career progression, skill development, and professional growth. The ability to build stronger relationships with colleagues and management enhances job satisfaction and teamwork. Employers are more likely to invest in the training and development of permanent staff, seeing them as long-term assets, which can lead to recognition and rewards for their contributions.

The stability of a permanent role allows for a predictable routine, which many find comforting. Permanent employees have the chance to fully integrate into the company culture, aligning with its values and goals. They also enjoy stronger legal protections and rights in the workplace, and the consistent income aids in better financial planning and stability.


The Drawbacks of Permanent Jobs

To be fair, permanent roles are not without their drawbacks. They often require adherence to a fixed schedule, offering less personal flexibility. The routine nature of permanent work can lead to boredom and burnout over time, and career advancement can sometimes be slower within the same company compared to switching between temp roles.

Permanent jobs might offer fewer opportunities for varied experiences compared to temp work, and the long-term commitment required may not appeal to those seeking diverse experiences or career exploration. The comfort of stability can sometimes come at the cost of excitement and growth.

Why Choose Lloyd Staffing?

Lloyd Staffing is a leading staffing firm that excels in connecting individuals with temporary work that can transition into meaningful, long-term opportunities. For job seekers, Lloyd Staffing provides access to a diverse range of temp positions that can enhance their skills and experience, and for employers, they offer a robust pool of temporary talent ready to meet immediate needs. Their expertise ensures that both parties find the best possible match, making Lloyd Staffing a trusted partner in today’s complex job market.  Lloyd has a deepline of temporary talent and has created a robust program known as LloydEmployed which offers the benefits and perks largely associated with a permanent job.  Lloyd does this to ensure retention of our valued workers and to minimize turnover.  Lloyd has had some temporary employees on the same assignment as long as five years!


The choice between temporary and permanent employment is deeply personal and depends on individual career goals, lifestyle preferences, and current circumstances. Temporary work offers flexibility, skill development, and networking opportunities, making it an increasingly viable and respected option. On the other hand, permanent jobs provide stability, benefits, and clear paths for career advancement. Understanding the pros and cons of each can help individuals make informed decisions that align with their personal and professional goals. With the right support, such as that offered by Lloyd Staffing, both job seekers and employers can navigate these options effectively to achieve their desired outcomes.

temporary vs permanent
temporary vs. permanent


Are you looking for a temporary or permanent job?
Visit our Job Board to apply for one of our employment opportunities.


Need Lloyd to Help You Hire?
If you have a current recruitment challenge, let us know.
Complete our Request Talent query to launch your search and we will have one of our Lloyd recruitment professionals reach out to you.


Related Lloyd Blogs