Most of us are familiar with this famous line, “I’m gonna make him an offer he can’t refuse.” ––
According to the American Film Institute, it is the second most famous movie quote of all time. Marlon Brando’s character Don Corleone says it in The Godfather and if your boss says it to you AFTER you have tendered your resignation, head for the door!
Counteroffers can be Highly Seductive
You just accepted a fabulous new position and now it’s time to tell your current boss. The next step can be difficult because you’ll be face with a dilemma: accepting a counteroffer – is it a smart move or likely to be a regret?
Counteroffers are designed to lure you back into a role you were ready to leave. It feels validating to receive one, as it suggests the company finally appreciates your value. However, this perception is often misleading.
In most cases, companies use counteroffers as a quick fix to a sudden problem. Career experts generally advise against accepting a counteroffer because your relationship with your employer changes the moment you indicate a desire to leave. Most employees who accept counteroffers leave within six to 12 months, either by choice or by termination.
If your employer truly valued you, why did it take your resignation to elicit a meaningful response? Counteroffers are often more about the company’s needs than yours. They provide a temporary solution for the employer while giving them time to find your replacement.
Assess Your Situation
If you’ve have previously expressed dissatisfaction with your position to your manager and nothing has changed, it’s probably time to move on. Once you decide to leave, submit a professional resignation letter and avoid further discussions
about staying. The reasons behind your initial desire to leave are unlikely to disappear.
The Lure of Counteroffers
It’s important to note that receiving a counteroffer can be highly flattering. It can make you feel valued and wanted, which is why it’s so tempting to stay. However, this temporary ego boost often doesn’t address the underlying issues that made you consider leaving in the first place.
Accepting a counteroffer can damage your trust and relationships within the company. Your loyalty will always be in question, and your colleagues may view your decision to stay as manipulative. Additionally, the initial reasons for wanting to leave often resurface, leading to future dissatisfaction.
Professional Reputation
Additionally, reneging on an accepted job offer can harm your professional reputation. Employers and recruiters invest time and resources in the hiring process, and backing out can be seen as unprofessional. This can impact future job opportunities as word spreads in professional networks.
An Expert Weighs In
According to Merrill Banks, Founder of Lloyd Staffing, “The average person wants to believe that their employers will finally appreciate their work and respond with more dollars, a new title or a perhaps increased respect for the job they do.” Says Banks,
“We almost always advise a candidate considering one to not do it and that’s not
because recruiters are putting their own needs first. It’s based on a long history and experience in the employment space and what we’ve seen happen to both sides who walk the counteroffer tightrope.”
Banks goes on to explain that a counteroffer is a temporary fix to a problem situation and almost always, the candidate will be the loser in the long run. He says that whether you believe it or not, your relationship with your employer will never be the same, no matter how much you think it won’t change. Lloyd has found that most employees who accept counteroffers leave within six to 12 months, either on their own or by termination.
So why is something that sounds so promising not really a good career move for you? First and foremost, the company knows you were almost out the door, mentally and physically. Your loyalty and commitment will always be in question, even in the best work relationships. That trust is very hard to restore since you will always be perceived as a flight risk. Perhaps just as damaging is how the work relationship between yourself and colleagues may sour. Those that believe your new title, duties or more money was a manipulative tactic may treat you differently, even your best buddies. And what about you? Something wasn’t quite right or you likely wouldn’t have considered a change in the first place. Are you simply settling for what’s comfortable, versus pushing yourself to the next level?
Banks says an individual must evaluate what you have before you give it up. If you have any sort of discontent, verbalize to your company leadership what you feel would make your role more personally satisfying to you. After that, if you’ve expressed your dissatisfaction with your position and your employer has not made any attempt to remedy the situation, it’s time to go. Make up your mind and stick with your decision. Turn in a courteous, professional resignation letter. Resign gracefully. Don’t leave any room for further discussion. Behave honorably and don’t burn any bridges. The reasons that prompted your initial desire to leave just don’t disappear overnight.
What to do when a Top Employee Resigns
Once the individual has resigned, a counteroffer is also not a smart strategy on your part. The time to have made them happy was before they got to this point. When a top employee resigns and is not swayed by a counteroffer, it can send shockwaves through your organization. To recover quickly and gracefully, the first step is to maintain open and honest communication. Address the team promptly and acknowledge the departing employee’s contributions, emphasizing the positive impact they’ve had. Reassure your team about the company’s stability and ongoing projects, while expressing confidence in their abilities to continue delivering excellence. By being transparent and showing strong leadership, you can help alleviate any immediate concerns and prevent rumors from spreading.
Next, focus on strategic planning and talent retention. Conduct exit interviews to understand the reasons behind the resignation and identify any underlying issues that might need addressing. Look internally for potential replacements or consider external hiring if necessary. Empower and support your remaining employees by providing opportunities for growth, recognizing their achievements, and ensuring they feel valued. Enhance team morale through team-building activities and by fostering a positive work environment. By proactively managing the transition and reinforcing a culture of appreciation and development, you can mitigate the risk of a mass exodus and ensure the continuity of your operations.
Conducting Effective Stay Interviews
To prevent valued employees from becoming flight risks, conduct periodic Stay Interviews. Focus on these five points:
- Job Satisfaction: Ask employees what they enjoy most and least about their job. This helps identify areas for improvement and reinforces positive aspects of their role.
- Career Goals: Discuss their career aspirations and how the company can support their professional growth. Provide opportunities for skill development and advancement.
- Work Environment: Inquire about their feelings towards the work environment and company culture. Address any negative feedback and make necessary changes to enhance the workplace atmosphere.
- Recognition and Reward: Ensure employees feel valued by recognizing their achievements and providing appropriate rewards. This can boost morale and job satisfaction.
- Work-Life Balance: Understand their needs for work-life balance and offer flexible arrangements if possible. A healthy work-life balance can reduce stress and increase loyalty.
Utilizing Temporary Staffing Firms
When an employee leaves and a counteroffer is not accepted, companies can also benefit from using temporary staffing firms such as Lloyd Staffing. These firms provide flexible contract professionals as a stop-gap measure, ensuring business continuity. Temporary staff can also be evaluated for permanent roles through temp-to-hire arrangements, helping companies manage staffing turnover effectively. Contract associates are available in a variety of skill areas and levels from entry level through C-Suite
Leaving the Door Open for Future Reconnection
Finally, if a valued employee decides to leave, maintain a positive relationship and leave the door open for future reconnection. Conduct an exit interview to fully understand their reasons for leaving and express your appreciation for their contributions.
As they move on to new horizons, send them off with a smile and a heartfelt “May the force be with you.” And remember, sometimes the best sequels come from the most unexpected reunions, so keep the door open for their return. After all, in the world of business, it’s never truly goodbye—just a “see you later.”
***********************
Has a top performer resigned?
Let us help you find the right person for your role. Hire Now.
Are you working, but unsatisfied and ready for a new role?
Visit our Job Board to apply for one of our employment opportunities